Zoning Board Of Appeal Hearing
The September 24, 2024, hearing will be held virtually via video teleconference and telephone via the Zoom Webinar event platform.
Please be advised of the following appeals to be heard on September 24, 2024, beginning at 9:30 a.m. and related announcements. All matters listed on this september 24, 2024 hearing agenda have been noticed in accordance with the enabling act.
Please be advised of the following participation instructions: The September 24, 2024, hearing will be held virtually via video teleconference and telephone via the zoom webinar event platform.
Interested persons can participate in the hearing REMOTELY by going to our online meeting. You may also participate by phone by calling into the Zoom Webinar at 301-715-8592 and entering the Webinar ID: 819 2218 4516 followed by # when prompted.
If you wish to offer testimony on an appeal, please sign up online. Please provide your name, address, the address and/or BOA number of the appeal on which you wish to speak, and if you wish to speak in support of or opposition to the project.
For individuals who need translation assistance, please notify the Board at least 48 HOURS in advance either by signing up online, calling 617-635-4775, or emailing zba.ambassador@boston.gov.
The ZBA Ambassador will be available within the Zoom Webinar Event from 8:30 - 9:30 a.m. to answer questions about ZBA procedures and offer instructions on how to participate in the hearing via Zoom. Questions and/or concerns can also be emailed to the ZBA Ambassador at zba.ambassador@boston.gov.
If you wish to offer comment within the meeting platform, please use the “Raise Hand” function that should appear on the bottom of your screen, if connected by computer or device, or dial *9, if connected by phone. On a computer or device, you will receive a request to unmute yourself from the event host. You must select yes before you can speak. On a phone, you will hear a prompt that the event host is asking you to unmute yourself. You must press *6 to unmute yourself before you can speak. Commenters will be asked to state their name, address and comment. Comments will be limited as time requires.
If you wish to offer testimony on an appeal, please log in to the hearing no later than 8:30 a.m. to ensure your connection is properly functioning. The hearing can also be viewed via livestream on the City ’s website. Closed captioning is available.
Interested persons who are unable to participate in the hearing remotely may make an appointment to offer testimony. Please notify the Board at least 48 HOURS in advance either by calling 617-635-4775 or emailing isdboardofappeal@boston.gov for accommodations to be made.
Members of the community are strongly encouraged to help facilitate the virtual hearing process by emailing letters in support of or opposition to an appeal to zbapublicinput@boston.gov in lieu of offering testimony online. It is strongly encouraged that written comments be submitted to the board at least 48 hours prior to the hearing. When doing so, please include in the subject line the BOA number, the address of the proposed project, and the date of the hearing.
Discussion Topics
-
APPROVAL OF THE HEARING MINUTES: 9:30AM
September 10, 2024
-
EXTENSIONS: 9:30AM
Case: BOA-1035621 Address: 3 Robinson Street Ward 15 Applicant: Joao Gomes
Case: BOA- 609358Address: 6-8 Parsons Street Ward 22 Applicant: Marc LaCasse, ESQ
Case: BOA- 609355 Address: 10 Parsons Street Ward 22 Applicant: Marc LaCasse, ESQ
Case: BOA- 898191 Address: 40 Mount Hood Road Ward 21 Applicant: Johanna Schneider
Case: BOA- 931560 Address: 149 Salem Street Ward 3 Applicant: Michael Dello Russo
Case: BOA- 948370 Address: 768-772 Tremont Street Ward 9 Applicant: Husam Al-Khateeb
Case: BOA- 948352 Address: 11 Heron Street Ward 20 Applicant: George Morancy, ESQ
Case: BOA- 948354 Address: 26 Heron Street Ward 20 Applicant: George Morancy, ESQ
Case: BOA- 1049883 Address: 850-852 Summer Street Ward 6 Applicant: John Gorman
Case: BOA- 1066449 Address: 6 Glover Court Ward 7 Applicant: Kevin Chiles
Case: BOA-1240760 Address: 46 Everett Street Ward 1 Applicant: Richard Lynds, Esq
Case: BOA#1240917 Address: 46 Everett Street Ward 1 Applicant: Richard Lynds, Esq
Case: BOA-1240765 Address: 48 Everett Street Ward 1 Applicant: Richard Lynds, Esq
Case: BOA#1240920 Address: 48 Everett Street Ward 1 Applicant: Richard Lynds, Esq
Case: BOA-1289438 Address: 211 West Third Street Ward 6 Applicant: Douglas Stefano, AIA, NCARB -
BOARD FINAL ARBITER: 9:30AM
Case: BOA- 1287036 Address: 1767 Washington Street Ward 9 Applicant: Marc LaCasse, ESQ
-
RECOMMENDATIONS: 9:30 AM
Case: BOA- 1629400 Address: 1-3 Center Plaza Ward: 3 Applicant: Meixiang Kass
Article(s): Art 45 Sec.14 Use: Conditional
Purpose: Meixiang Kass the owner of Pretty Chic is a tenant (suite 33) located at 3 Center Plaza, Boston, MA 02108 in Sola Salon. Meixiang Kass the owner and tenant (suite 33) is applying for Permit to add Body Art. She is applying to the Board of Health for her permit. Work performed under ALT1497937 issued 8/14/23.
Case: BOA-1606999 Address: 141 West Canton Street Ward: 4 Applicant: Peter Bemis
Article(s): Art. 64 Sec. 09 Town House/Row House Extensions into Rear Yard - 4.Town House/Row House Extensions into Rear Yard. Notwithstanding any contrary provision of this Article or Code, any Proposed Project that otherwise meets the applicable use and dimensional requirements of this Article shall be conditional if such Proposed Project involves the extension of a Town House or Row House into a rear yard, where such extension: (b) involves the addition of a porch or balcony, other than a roof deck, above the first story.
Purpose: Extension of existing steel and glass deck. Remove existing galvanized steel rails for installation of 4.5 ft. x 13.5 ft. steel and glass deck extension with new rails and balustrade. Provide new footings and sonotube piers for deck support. Repair underground recharge system and reset bluestone pavers as required. Install new 6ft. privacy fence with integrated storage cabinets and relocated grill. Replace in kind existing rotted wood stair and lower storage.
Case: BOA- 1616914 Address: 51 Wyman Street Ward: 10 Applicant: Adam Ricci
Article(s): Art. 55 Sec. 09 Maximum Floor Area Ratio exceeded 0.87 proposed; 0.6 max allowed
Purpose : New bathroom and partition walls in basement for new home office. Extending living space into the basement.
Case: BOA-1603914 Address: 990-996 Dorchester Avenue Ward: 13 Applicant: Kevin Gonzalez
Article(s): Art.06 Sec.04 Conditional
Purpose: Remove proviso and grant to this petitioner only under Alt1306115, BOA1314013 (No Work)
Case: BOA- 1585024 Address: 14 Hancock Street Ward: 13 Applicant: Ayaz Shah
Article(s):Art. 06 Sec. 04 Other Protectional Conditions - Removal of previous BOA proviso order "to petitioner only" requested
Purpose: Remove proviso (No Work)
Case: BOA- 1600852 Address: 10 Brewer Street Ward: 19 Applicant: Steven Cohen
Article(s): Article 55, Section 40 Off Street Parking & Loading Req - Proposed parking in required front yard
Purpose: Curb cut and one off street accessory residential parking space.
Case: BOA- 1614441 Address: 66 Farquhar Street Ward: 20 Applicant: John Pulgini
Article(s): Article 67, Section 9 Floor Area Ratio Excessive - Applicant will need to seek relief for the proposed FAR of .75 Article 67, Section 9 Bldg Height Excessive (Stories) - Applicant will need to seek relief for three stories (existing non conforming). Article 67, Section 9 Front Yard Insufficient - Applicant will need to seek relief for Front yard setback of 17.9' (existing non conforming).Article 67, Section 9 Side Yard Insufficient - Applicant will need to seek relief for the Right side yard setback of 4.23' (Existing non conforming) Article 67, Section 32 Off Street Parking - Applicant will need to seek relief for TWO off street parking spaces.
Purpose: Construct a three story rear addition to the existing dwelling on the property, construct third floor dormers and second floor porch, and change occupancy from single family to two family -
HEARINGS: 9:30AM
Case: BOA- 1585854 Address: 80 Spring Park Avenue Ward 19 Applicant: Michael Welsh
Article(s): Article 55, Section 9 Add'l Lot Area Insufficient Article 55, Section 9 Floor Area Ratio Excessive
Article 55, Section 9 Bldg Height Excessive (Feet) Article 55, Section 9 Bldg Height Excessive (Stories)
Article 55, Section 9 Front Yard Insufficient Article 55, Section 9 Side Yard Insufficient Article 55, Section 9 Rear Yard Insufficient Article 55, Section 9 Usable Open Space Insufficient Article 55 Sect 40Off Street Parking & Loading Req Off street parking is only provided for unit 3. 2 additional spaces are required.
Purpose: New construction of four story three family dwelling on vacant lot. New building to have two garage parking spaces, sprinklers, and an elevator exclusively for the triplex unit on floors two through four.
Case: BOA- 1627266 Address: 103-105 Neponset Avenue Ward 18 Applicant: James McCabe
Article(s): Art. 67 Sec. 09 Side Yard Insufficient
Purpose: Erect new two level rear porch to existing house.
Case: BOA- 1530242 Address: 69 Thetford Avenue Ward 17 Applicant: Urban Determination/ Vernon Woodworth
Article(s): Article 65, Section 8 Use RegulationsThree Family is forbidden in a 2F 5000 Sub district Article 65, Section 9 Floor Area Ratio Excessive Article 65, Section 9 Side Yard Insufficient Article 65 Section 41Off Street Parking and Loading Off street parking is insufficient
Purpose: Change occupancy from 2 family to 3 family. Convert third floor into a dwelling unit. Install NFPA 13D sprinkler system third floor only. Rebuild existing front stair to second floor and extend to third for second means of egress.
Case: BOA- 1636369 Address: 608 Gallivan Boulevard Ward 16 Applicant: James Christopher
Article(s): Art. 65 Sec. 08 Forbidden Multifamily use Article 65, Section 9 Floor Area Ratio ExcessiveMax. allowed: 0.5 Proposed: 0.69 Article 65, Section 9 Bldg Height Excessive (Stories) Max. allowed: 2.5 Proposed: 3 Article 65, Section 9 Side Yard Insufficient Min. required: 10’ Proposed: 8.2' Art. 65 Sec. 02Conformity with Existing Building Alignment Street modal calculation not provided to verify its compliance. Article 65, Section 42Application of Dimensional Req 65.42.6 Left Side wall of building not parallel to side lot line.
Purpose: The owner seeks to raze the existing 2 family structure, and erect a new 3 story, 12 unit residential building with 20 below grade parking spaces on the existing 20,000 SF lot as per the attached plans.
Case: BOA-1452431 Address: 12 Trull Street Ward 15 Applicant: Cesar DaSilva
Article(s): Art.65 Sec. 8 Use: Forbidden MFR in 3F Article 65, Section 8.2 Use Regulations: Basement Units Basement unit – Forbidden Article 65, Section 9 Floor Area Ratio Excessive Article 65, Section 9 Bldg Height Excessive (Stories) Article 65, Section 9.2 Dim Regs: Location of Main Entrance Basement unit
Purpose: Change of occupancy from 2 family to 4 family dwelling. Scope include new side exterior egress stair, new fire alarm/sprinkler system, unit separation, and relocation of the utility meters.
Case: BOA- 1556446 Address: 2080 Washington Street Ward 8 Applicant: Jonathan Smalls
Article(s): Art. 50, Section 24 Use: ConditionalProposed project will use building for Cultural Use more
specifically for Dance Studios, which is a Conditional. Art. 50 Sec. 37 Boulevard Planning DistrictThe proposed project is subject to Boulevard Planning District Review.(Design Review) Art. 50, Section 25 Dimensional Regulations The proposed project will exceed the 20' a rear yard setback.
Purpose: Change occupancy to Cultural use as dance studio, renovate existing building, add 2 floors (was formally 2 story) on top of existing foundation. Building to be used as a dance studio.
Case: BOA- 1615346 Address: 374 East Eighth Street Ward 7 Applicant: Braden Abrams Reid
Article(s): Article 68, Section 8 Rear Yard Insufficient Article 68, Section 8 Side Yard Insufficient Article 68, Section 8 Front Yard Insufficient Article 68, Section 8 Floor Area Ratio ExcessiveYou need relief from the BOA for the said violations
Purpose: Amendment to ALT1555165. Build garage attached to back of existing house and additional story on existing house per architectural plans
Case: BOA- 1628161 Address: 850-852 Summer Street Ward 6 Applicant: Krysta-Lyn Martinelli
Article(s): Art. 09 Sec. 02 Nonconforming Use Change <25% -Conditional Art. 68 Sec. 07 Use Regs. -Use Conditional
Purpose: Previous scope: lease 850 Summer Street, unit #202 on the second floor for a wellness studio space.
Clarification of scope of work: Change occupancy of what is known to be suite #206 (aka#5) from office use to a
professional office (Yoga fitness studio) No work to be performed beyond level 1 cosmetic work
Case: BOA- 1613836 Address: 1 Laurel Street Ward 2 Applicant: Margaret Tannoury
Article(s): Art. 09 Sec. 01 Extension of Non Conforming Use Article 62, Section 8Floor Area Ratio Excessive
Purpose: Excavate and lower slab height of existing finished basement to increase ceiling height. Change ½ bath in the basement to full bath. Replace existing bulkhead walls and steel door with new concrete bulkhead walls and glass door.
*Single Family #ALT633782/2016
Case: BOA- 1565654 Address: 156-164 Bunker Hill Street Ward 2 Applicant: John Carey, ESQ
Article(s): Article 62, Section 8 Rear Yard Insufficient Article 62, Section 8 Floor Area Ratio Excessive
Article 62, Section 8 Bldg Height Excessive (Feet) Article 62, Section 8 Usable Open Space Insufficient
Article 62, Section 29 Off Street Parking Insufficient
Purpose: Erect new three story addition containing four dwelling units above existing one story building containing a restaurant and convenience store.
Case: BOA- 1633229 Address: 609-611 Bennington Street Ward 1 Applicant: Brooke Charter School
Article(s): ARTICLE 53; SECTION 53 5Dimensional Regulations (Table F)EBR 4 Insufficient rear yard setback
Art. 53 Sec. 56 Off Street Parking Insufficient parking
Purpose: Change occupancy from a two (2) family dwelling (See 336/1915) to Educational Use. Interior renovations only. Clarification: Change occupancy from a two family to an Educational USE detached dwelling as an extension of the (Brooke Charter School) and renovate structures 1st floor for classroom use (28 students) and second floor for school administrative office use and incidental kitchen. Renovations shall include a newly proposed handicap ramp in rear to create a clear pathway to the existing school located on the 96 Horace street lot
Case: BOA- 1575584 Address: 81 Lexington Street Ward 1 Applicant: James Christopher
Article(s): Art.53 Sec. 08 Use: ForbiddenMFR Forbidden Art.53 Sec. 08 Use: ForbiddenBasement units Forbidden
Art.53 Sec. 08 Use: Forbidden Local Retail Forbidden Article 53, Section 9 Rear Yard Insufficient Article 53, Section 9 Side Yard Insufficient Article 53, Section 9 Bldg Height Excessive (Feet) Article 53, Section 9Bldg Height Excessive (Stories) Article 53, Section 9 Floor Area Ratio Excessive Article 53, Section 57.2Conformity Ex Bldg Alignment
Art. 53, Section 56 Off Street Parking Insufficient
Purpose: Erect a 3 story mixed used building on newly created lot; 3,706sqft. Building consisting of 1 Local Retail space at grade and 8 residential units. Scope includes basement units, balconies, and common roof deck. See ALT1553019 for subdivision. Demolition of existing building on separate permit
Case: BOA- 1637997 Address: 55 Chelsea Street Ward 1 Applicant: Paola Alzate
Article(s): Art. 53, Section 8 Use: ForbiddenGeneral Retail Forbidden Art. 53, Section 8 Use: ForbiddenMulti Family Dwelling Forbidden Article 53, Section 9 Rear Yard Insufficient Article 53, Section 9 Side Yard Insufficient Article 53, Section 9 Front Yard Insufficient Article 53, Section 9 Usable Open Space Insufficient Article 53, Section 9 Floor Area Ratio Excessive Article 53, Section 9 Add'l Lot Area Insufficient Article 53, Section 9Lot Area Insufficient Art. 53 Sec. 09.3 Location of Main Entrance Article 53, Section 52 Roof Structure Restrictions Art. 53, Section 56 Off Street Parking Insufficient Art. 25 Sec. 5 Flood Hazard Districts
Purpose: Change of occupancy to Two General Retail (core/shell) and Five Residential units. Scope of work to include additions on levels 2 and 3 with complete rehab/reconfiguration of existing building including upgrades to life safety (FA/FP). -
RE-DISCUSSIONS: 11:30 AM
Case: BOA-1600988 Address: 2193-2201 Commonwealth Avenue Ward 22 Applicant: Mr. G’s Corner, LLC
Article(s): Aft. 51 Sec. 16 Forbidden Use
Purpose: Change of use and occupancy to add a new proposed local liquor store with retail market use at the Premises in place of existing commercial use.
Case: BOA- 1521952 Address: 259R-259RF Market Street Ward 22 Applicant: Penny Investments, LLC
Article(s): Article 51 Section 9.4 Dim Reg: Location of Main Entrance Article 51, Section 57.13 Two or More Dwellings on Same Lot Dwelling at rear of another Dwelling Article 51, Section 8 Use: Forbidden Three family - Forbidden Article 51, Section 8 Use: Forbidden Townhouses – Forbidden Article 51, Section 9 Lot Frontage Insufficient Article 51, Section 9 Bldg Height Excessive (Stories)
Purpose: Erect (3) new 3 story townhomes in a newly created rear lot (Lot B, 10,845 sq. ft.) behind the existing two family dwelling, which will remain on the street facing lot. Each townhome features garaged parking for two cars and top story decks. See ALT1484754 & ALT1515523 for subdivision applications.
Case: BOA-1521950 Address: 257 Market Street Ward 22 Applicant: Penny Investments, LLC
Article(s): Article 51, Section 9 Rear Yard Insufficient Article 51, Section 56 Off Street Parking Insufficient
Article 9, Section 2 Change in Non Conforming Use Decrease in lot size to existing Non conforming use.
Purpose: Filed with ERT1480650, the intent is to subdivide the lot, retain the existing two family on the lot designated as 257 Market St, and build a new multifamily building on the new rear lot. Subdivision of Parcel 2202571000 to create two new parcels; Lot A 5,857sqft & Lot B 10,845sqft.
Case:BOA-1353108 Address: 6 Dana Avenue Ward 18 Applicant: Luis Matute
Article(s): Article 69, Section 8 Use: Forbidden - Basement units Art. 69 Sec. 29.5 Off St.Prk'g:Design - Parking space dimensions. Article 69 Section 29 Off Street Parking & Loading Req - Proposing to legalize 8 existing parking spaces. Required for "new" basement unit: 2 more spaces. Article 69 Section 12 Exceeding allowed FAR extending living space for the "new" unit into the basement. Art. 10 Sec. 01 Limitation of parking areas - Parking spaces (P1, P6, P7 and P8) are located on the front yard (Pingree Street)
Purpose: Applying for change of use and occupancy, existing unit No. 07/no work. Unit 7 was never finished legally on paper construction was completed, previous owner passed away during the process. Confirmed occupancy as a 6 residential units and commercial office space (commercial unit is one at issue) change to 7 residential units according to drawings and specifications. Legalize 8 existing parking spaces.
Case: BOA-1587883 Address: 40 Elmont Street Ward 14 Applicant: Carlos Ferreira
Article(s): Article 65, Section 9 Rear Yard Insufficient Article 65, Section 9 Side Yard Insufficient Article 65, Section 9 Front Yard Insufficient Article 65, Section 9 Bldg Height Excessive (Feet) Article 65, Section 9 Usable Open Space Insufficient Article 65, Section 9 Bldg Height Excessive (Stories) Article 65, Section 9 Floor Area Ratio Excessive
Purpose: Plans amends ERT1353260, changing empty spaces in basement into a bedroom bath and closet. Exterior will be changed from wood to light gauge cold form
Case: BOA-1625940 Address: 400-408 West Broadway Ward 6 Applicant: George Morancy, ESQ-ARTICLE 80
Article(s): Art. 68 Sec. 07 Use Regs. Sit down Restaurant USE -Conditional
Article 68, Section 33 Off-Street Parking & Loading Req Insufficient parking
Purpose: Change of Occupancy from 36 Residential units, 36 parking spaces, and 1 retail store see ERT884395 to 36 Residential Units, 36 Parking spaces, and RESTAURANT which is a conditional use.
Case: BOA- 1615937 Address: 297 Newbury Street Ward 5 Applicant: Ember Gardens Boston LLC/ Shane Hyde-CANNABIS
Article(s): Art. 08 Sec. 07 Use: Forbidden *Cannabis Establishment-provided that any cannabis establishment shall be sited at least one-half mile or 2,640 feet from another existing cannabis establishment and at least 500 feet from a pre-existing public or private school providing education in kindergarten or any of grades 1 through 12. Distances shall be determined from the nearest lot line of the proposed establishment to the nearest lot line of an existing establishment or school.
Use approval shall be applicable to the applicant only Art. 08 Sec.07 Use: Conditional
Purpose: Change Occupancy from Retail to cannabis dispensary. Renovation of interior space to fit out as retail space (cannabis dispensary). Some interior non bearing walls will be removed and new walls constructed.
Case: BOA-1607841 Address: 200 State Street Ward 3 Applicant: Commodore Builders
Article(s): Art. 45, Section 1Use: ForbiddenMuseum use (not in ground level)
Purpose: Change of Occupancy to include museum use. The scope of work for this project includes an interior fit out for the Museum of Illusion. The scope of work for this project includes new walls, bathroom, flooring, architectural finishes and MEP work to accommodate the space.
Case: BOA-1304433 Address: 10 Thompson Square Ward 2 Applicant: Sing Ming Chan
Article(s): Art. 62 Sec. 14 Usable open space insufficient Article 62, Section 14 Excessive f.a.r.
Article 62, Section 14 Excessive height Article 62, Section 14 Insufficient rear yard setback Article 62, Section 29 Off-Street Loading Insufficient - None proposed Art. 62 Sec. 62-29 Off street parking requirements - None proposed
Purpose: Erect a new mixed use building with commercial space (RETAIL) on first floor and 12 dwelling units above.
Existing building to be razed under separate permit. *4.10.23: Reduced project scope at ZBA to 12 units and 4 stories -
INTERPRETATION: 1:00PM
Case: BOA-1602742 Address: 123-125 Broad Street Ward 3 Applicant: 125 Broad Street LLC
Article(s):Art. 32 Sec. 04 GCOD Applicability - Commissioner's Bulletin 2015 02 Substantial Rehabilitate
Purpose: The petitioner seeks a determination that the Inspectional Services Department erred in issuing a refusal letter citing Art 32 Sec 04 GCOD Applicability.